Best Deer Tongue Lettuce Seeds for Home Gardens
For gardeners looking specifically for deer tongue lettuce, the strongest matches are Amish Deer Tongue seed packets in different quantities and packaging styles, plus a red-leaf selection. Everwilde Farms offers large packets and resealable Gold Vault packaging, while Thresh Seed Co. is a smaller-packet choice. The Black Seeded Simpson option is a different lettuce variety for shoppers who want an alternative leaf lettuce rather than deer tongue.
| Product | Best For | Standout Feature |
|---|---|---|
| Everwilde Farms Amish Deer Tongue | Large seed supply | 1,000 seeds and resealable storage bag |
| Thresh Seed Co. Amish Deer Tongue | Smaller planting | 150 seeds; cut-and-come-again planting |
| Everwilde Farms Red Deer Tongue | Red-leaf selection | Gold Vault packaging |
| Everwilde Farms Organic Amish Deer Tongue | Organic seed preference | Organic seeds in resealable packaging |
| Survival Garden Seeds Black Seeded Simpson | Alternative leaf lettuce | Quick-growing, repeat-harvest variety |
Everwilde Farms Amish Deer Tongue Seeds
This packet contains 1,000 Amish Deer Tongue lettuce seeds, making it the best fit among these picks for gardeners planning a larger sowing or multiple planting rounds. The product is listed as non-GMO, and the packet displays current lab test data, according to its features.
Its Gold Vault triple-layer Mylar packaging is described as providing three times longer storage than paper or plastic packaging. A resealable, reusable zipper bag helps gardeners store unused seeds after opening. Choose this option if a large quantity and protected storage are priorities.
Limitation: A 1,000-seed packet may be more than needed for a small garden or a first trial planting.
Thresh Seed Co. Amish Deer Tongue Seeds
Thresh Seed Co. supplies 150 Amish Deer Tongue lettuce seeds. This smaller packet is better for gardeners who want to try the variety or plant a more limited area without starting with a bulk quantity.
The listing describes the Amish variety as having thick, crunchy leaves and reliable production. It also says the lettuce works well for cut-and-come-again planting when sown thickly. That makes it a relevant choice for growers who want to harvest leaves over time instead of relying on a single large picking.
Best for: A modest home planting or a gardener interested in the variety’s firmer leaf texture. Limitation: The 150-seed quantity is smaller than the bulk Everwilde Farms packet.
Everwilde Farms Red Deer Tongue Seeds
This packet offers 1,000 Red Deer Tongue lettuce seeds. It is the most direct choice in this list for shoppers searching specifically for a red deer tongue selection, rather than the Amish type or a different lettuce variety.
The product features identify the seeds as non-GMO and state that current lab test data appears on the packet. Like the other Everwilde Gold Vault options here, it uses triple-layer Mylar foil packaging described as providing three times longer storage than paper or plastic. The resealable zipper bag can be reused for excess seeds.
Choose this if the red deer tongue type and a large packet are your priorities. Limitation: The supplied product details do not describe leaf color intensity, flavor, or growing instructions.
Everwilde Farms Organic Amish Deer Tongue
This packet contains 500 Organic Amish Deer Tongue leaf lettuce seeds. It is a suitable middle-ground quantity for gardeners who want the Amish deer tongue type and prefer an organic seed option. The product features describe the seeds as organic and say current lab test data is shown on the packet.
The packet uses Everwilde Farms’ Gold Vault packaging, with triple-layer Mylar foil and a resealable, reusable zipper bag. That can be useful when seeds remain after planting and need to be kept in their original package.
Best for: Gardeners seeking organic Amish Deer Tongue seeds without choosing the 1,000-seed packet. Limitation: The listing details do not provide specific cultivation instructions or describe the lettuce’s texture.
Survival Garden Seeds Black Seeded Simpson
Black Seeded Simpson is not deer tongue lettuce, so it is best treated as an alternative rather than a direct match. The listing describes it as a loose-leaf heirloom with light green, ruffled leaves and a sweet, mild taste. It is intended for gardeners who want another leaf lettuce option for fresh salads.
The product features say this variety matures quickly, can regrow after outer leaves are picked, and handles warm spells better than most lettuce seeds. Those points make it a useful comparison for shoppers prioritizing repeated harvests or performance during variable weather.
Choose this if an alternative loose-leaf lettuce is acceptable. Limitation: Avoid it if you specifically need Amish or red deer tongue seeds.
Buying Guide: How To Choose Deer Tongue Lettuce Seeds
Which packet size fits your garden?
Compare seed quantity with your planned planting area and how often you expect to sow. The listed choices range from 150 seeds to 1,000 seeds, with a 500-seed organic option between them. A smaller packet can suit a trial or limited bed, while a larger packet provides more seeds for repeated plantings. The supplied product details do not give a recommended seed count per row or square foot.
Do you want Amish or red deer tongue?
Amish Deer Tongue appears in the Thresh Seed Co. and Everwilde Farms options. Everwilde Farms also offers Red Deer Tongue. Compare the variety name on the packet rather than assuming the red and Amish products are identical. The available descriptions provide more detail about thick, crunchy leaves for the Amish variety than for the red selection.
Does organic status or storage packaging matter?
The 500-seed Everwilde Farms option is identified as organic. Other Everwilde Farms products in this list are described as non-GMO and use Gold Vault packaging. The packaging is presented as a storage feature, but seed longevity still depends on storage conditions; follow the packet guidance for handling and storage.
Are you open to other leaf lettuce varieties?
If deer tongue is essential, select a product labeled Amish Deer Tongue or Red Deer Tongue. Black Seeded Simpson is a distinct lettuce with its own described traits, including ruffled leaves and repeat harvesting. It may suit a broader lettuce garden, but it is not a substitute when the specific deer tongue variety is required.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Amish and Red Deer Tongue lettuce seeds?
They are listed as separate deer tongue selections. The product details describe Amish Deer Tongue as having thick, crunchy leaves, but do not provide comparable growing or flavor details for Red Deer Tongue.
Which deer tongue seed packet has the most seeds?
The Everwilde Farms Amish and Red Deer Tongue packets each list 1,000 seeds. The organic Amish packet lists 500, and Thresh Seed Co. lists 150.
Which option is identified as organic?
Everwilde Farms’ 500-seed Amish Deer Tongue packet is identified as organic in the supplied product features.
Can Amish Deer Tongue lettuce be harvested more than once?
Thresh Seed Co. says its Amish variety works well for cut-and-come-again plantings when sown thickly. Follow the seed packet’s directions for sowing and harvesting.
Is Black Seeded Simpson a deer tongue lettuce?
No. It is a separate loose-leaf lettuce variety and is included as an alternative for shoppers considering other leaf lettuce seeds.