Best Bag Attachments for Push Lawn Mowers: Five Replacement Picks
The best bag attachment for a push lawn mower depends on the mower type and the part you need: a complete catcher for a reel mower or a replacement fabric bag for a walk-behind mower. The American Lawn Mower GC91416 is a fit-specific choice for certain 14- and 16-inch reel mowers. The other picks are replacement bags for selected MTD, Troy-Bilt, Craftsman, and related models; their frames are not included. Match the part number and mower model before ordering.
| Product | Best For | What Is Included |
|---|---|---|
| American Lawn Mower GC91416 | Specified 14- and 16-inch reel mowers | Grass catcher |
| 964-04007A compatible bag | Selected 21-inch MTD-family mowers | Bag only; no frame |
| 964-04154A MTD replacement | Specified Troy-Bilt and related models | Bag only; no frame |
| 964-04154A Craftsman replacement | Listed Craftsman mower models | Fabric bag only |
| GC91416 reel mower catcher | 14- and 16-inch push reel mowers | Grass catcher |
American Lawn Mower GC91416 Reel Catcher
Best for: Owners of listed American Lawn Mower, Great States, Earthwise, Scotts, or Black & Decker 14- and 16-inch reel mower models. This product is selected because its listed fitment names mower sizes, brands, and specific model numbers, making it easier to compare against a mower’s identification label.
The catcher has a plastic bottom, rot-resistant polyester fabric, and a heavy-duty wire frame. Listed models include 1204-14, 1304-14, 1415-16, 204-14, and 415-16, among others. Check the full model list before purchase rather than relying on brand or cutting width alone.
Limitation: The stated fit is limited to specified reel mowers; it is not presented as a universal bag for walk-behind rotary mowers.
964-04007A Replacement Grass Collection Bag
Best for: Owners whose mower calls for one of the listed 664-04007 or 964-04007 family part numbers. The long cross-reference list and named fitment for selected models, including CC439, CC469, CC46ES, CC46M, and CC46MZ, make this a useful option when replacing an existing 21-inch mower bag.
This is a grass collection bag intended for compatible walk-behind mower setups. Compare the mower’s manual and existing bag part number with the listed numbers, which include 664-04011, 664-04027, and 964-04034.
Limitation: The listing explicitly says the grass catcher frame is not included. Avoid this option if you need a complete catcher assembly or cannot verify the required part number.
964-04154A MTD Grass Bag Replacement
Best for: Owners of compatible Troy-Bilt and related walk-behind mower models that use part 964-04154A or 964-04154. The listing names Troy-Bilt series 11A and 12A and models such as TB110, TB210, TB260, TB280ES, TB130, TB230, and TB280. It also identifies several related brands, including Yard Machines, Yard Man, Arnold, Remington, Columbia, and Murray.
Choose this replacement when the mower’s part number or model matches the listed fitment. The product is described as the grass bag itself, rather than a complete collection assembly.
Limitation: The frame and other parts are not included. Check whether the existing frame is usable and confirm the exact mower model before ordering.
964-04154A Craftsman-Compatible Grass Bag
Best for: Craftsman mower owners who need a replacement bag matching part 964-04154A or 964-04154 and one of the listed models. The fitment includes Precision Plus 21-inch and model codes such as B25F, B25E, A2BR, A25F, and A23P, as well as numerous 247-series numbers.
This pick is selected for its detailed Craftsman model references. Compare the full model number on the mower—not just the brand or 21-inch description—with the product’s compatibility list. It is identified as the fabric bag for a compatible walk-behind mower.
Limitation: The frame is not included. This is not the right choice if the frame is missing or if your mower model is not listed or otherwise confirmed by its manual.
GC91416 Catcher For 14- And 16-Inch Reel Mowers
Best for: Buyers looking for a catcher described for 14- and 16-inch push reel mowers. The listed features say it collects clippings during mowing and is designed for straightforward attachment, removal, and emptying. It is selected as a simple size-based alternative for reel mower owners comparing catcher options.
Choose this if your mower is a push reel model and the product’s size description matches. A catcher can collect clippings as you mow, reducing the need to rake them afterward.
Limitation: The supplied details do not provide a specific brand or model-number compatibility list. Verify fit with the mower documentation or seller before purchase.
Buying Guide: How To Choose A Push Mower Bag
Does your mower use a reel catcher or a replacement bag?
Reel mowers and walk-behind rotary mowers may use different collection systems. The GC91416 listings describe catchers for 14- and 16-inch reel mowers. The 964-series products are replacement bags associated with specified walk-behind mower models. Identify the mower type before comparing products.
Which part number and model should you check?
Look for the mower’s full model number on its identification label and check the owner’s manual for the collection-bag part number. Compare those details with the product listing. A shared brand name or cutting width alone does not establish compatibility.
Do you need the frame too?
Some listings explicitly sell the fabric bag only. The 964-04007A and both 964-04154A options state that the frame is not included. If the original frame is damaged or missing, confirm whether a separate frame is required before choosing a bag-only replacement.
How should you compare similar listings?
Prioritize exact part-number matches, then compare the listed model numbers and brands. For reel catchers, verify both mower type and cutting width. When a listing lacks a detailed model list, consult the manual or confirm fit before ordering instead of assuming universal compatibility.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are push mower grass bags universal?
No. These products identify specific mower types, part numbers, brands, or models. Check the mower’s manual and model label before buying.
Does a replacement grass bag include its frame?
Not necessarily. The listed 964-04007A and 964-04154A bags are described as bag-only products, with no frame included.
Can a reel mower catcher fit a rotary mower?
The listed GC91416 products are described for 14- and 16-inch reel mowers. Their supplied details do not establish fit for rotary walk-behind mowers.
What does part number 964-04154A indicate?
It identifies a replacement bag referenced for selected compatible mowers. Confirm the full mower model and part number because not every mower from a named brand is necessarily a match.
What should I do if my model is not listed?
Check the owner’s manual or contact the seller with the complete mower model and current bag part number to confirm compatibility.